How do hackers use your old leaked passwords?

The short answer

Credential stuffing is when criminals take email and password pairs from old leaks and let software try them on other sites, getting in wherever you reused the password.

Animated diagram: How do hackers use your old leaked passwords?

Credential stuffing

Credential stuffing is what happens to a password after it leaks. Criminals keep your email and password together as a pair, in lists that get packaged, sold and traded for years. The pairs come from hacked websites, and from infostealer malware that steals logins saved on a computer. So a password that leaked ten years ago can still be sitting in one of those lists today.

The defense is old and simple. Use one password per account, and turn on a second sign-in step, called MFA (multi-factor authentication). A unique password means a leak from one site opens nothing else. A second step means a correct password alone isn’t enough to get in.

What credential stuffing actually does

Software takes each email and password pair from a list and types it into the login forms of other sites: email, shops, streaming. Each account gets about one try. That’s why it blends in with normal logins instead of looking like someone guessing over and over. MITRE ATT&CK, a public catalog of attacker techniques, lists it as technique T1110.004.

The scale is real. Verizon looked at two years of login logs from SSO (single sign-on) providers. Credential stuffing was a median 19 percent of daily login attempts, and 44 percent on the worst day. In 2024, about 576,000 Roku accounts were affected. Roku said it had no indication it was the source, and that the logins were likely taken from another source.

How a reused password opens the door

  1. A site gets breached. Or infostealer malware grabs logins saved on a computer. Either way, your email and password end up together as a pair.
  2. The pair joins a list. These lists are packaged, sold and traded for years, so an old leak keeps circulating.
  3. Software tries other sites. It types the pair into login forms elsewhere, about one try per account, so it looks like a normal login.
  4. Reuse lets it in. Wherever you used the same password and have no second sign-in step, the login succeeds.

The attacker doesn’t break anything. They simply log in. In the 2024 Snowflake customer attacks, Mandiant found that attackers signed in with credentials stolen by infostealers. The accounts had no MFA, so only a valid username and password were needed. Mandiant found no breach of Snowflake’s own systems.

An old password is not a harmless password

Many people think a password from years ago doesn’t matter anymore. It does, as long as you still use it somewhere. In the Snowflake case, some stolen logins dated back to November 2020 and still worked years later. A small tweak doesn’t help either. Troy Hunt’s data showed a “new” password that was just the old one with two exclamation marks added. The FTC (Federal Trade Commission) says to change accounts that use a similar password too. A leaked password stays dangerous until you change it everywhere you used it.

What to do

  • Run a password checkup today. In Chrome, open Google Password Manager and choose Checkup. On iPhone with iOS 18 or later, open the Passwords app and go to Security.
  • Change everything it flags as compromised or reused, starting with your email account.
  • Give each account its own new password, not the old one with an exclamation mark added.
  • Turn on a second sign-in step wherever you can, so a correct password alone can’t open the account.

#CredentialStuffing#PasswordReuse#DataBreach#PasswordManager#Passwords#2FA#CyberSecurity#OnlineSafety#InfoSec

Watch it in 60 seconds