Is your smart TV's microphone listening in standby?

The short answer

Sometimes. With hands-free listening, a TV can keep its microphone open in standby, but unless it has been hacked, it should only be waiting for a wake word, like "Hi LG."

The smart TV microphone

A smart TV is a TV with a microphone for voice control. You talk to it, and it changes the channel or starts a search. On LG TVs, voice recognition is turned off by default. But if you turn on hands-free mode, the TV can keep its microphone open, even in standby.

To respond without you touching the remote, the TV needs a signal: the wake word. It’s a short phrase, like “Hi LG.” Until that word is spoken, it shouldn’t do anything with what it hears. The other way to talk to it is the microphone button on the remote: you press it, then you speak.

What the microphone actually does in standby

In hands-free mode, the TV constantly compares the sound in the living room to the wake word. According to LG, this detection happens locally, inside the TV. Sound that doesn’t contain the word is not stored, turned into text, or sent anywhere: it’s erased right away. That’s the manufacturer’s claim.

Everything changes when the TV hears the word, or when you press the microphone button. It then records your sentence. On LG TVs, a session lasts about eighteen seconds at most. This figure only applies to LG.

How the TV handles your voice

  1. The TV waits for the word. In standby, with hands-free listening, it compares the sound in the living room to the phrase. According to LG, sound without that word is erased.
  2. It records your sentence. After the word or a press of the microphone button, it captures what you say, for about eighteen seconds at most on LG TVs.
  3. The sentence goes to the server. A server turns your voice into text so the TV can understand your request.
  4. A third party may get involved. At LG, this information can be processed by service providers that handle voice recognition. Samsung warned as early as 2015 that your words could be passed on to a third party.

The result: according to LG, what leaves your living room is the sentence that follows the wake word, not everything said there. But that sentence really does leave your home.

TV off doesn’t mean microphone off

Many people think a TV that’s off can’t hear anything. That’s true only if it hasn’t been hacked. In 2017, WikiLeaks published the Vault 7 documents. They revealed Weeping Angel, a tool of the CIA, the United States intelligence service. On some Samsung F series TVs, its “Fake-Off” mode made it look as if the TV was off. Meanwhile, it recorded the room and sent the sound to a hidden CIA server. This was a hack, not the normal way a TV works.

What to do

  • Turn off hands-free listening. On Samsung TVs, that’s Voice Wake-up, under Settings, All Settings, General & Privacy, then Voice. The label can vary, and this setting doesn’t exist on every model or in every region.
  • If you want to keep voice wake-up on a Samsung TV, at least set its sensitivity to low.
  • Keep the microphone button on the remote: it still works once hands-free listening is turned off.
  • On LG TVs, voice recognition is turned off by default: only turn on hands-free mode if you really need it.

#SmartTV#TVMicrophone#Privacy#CyberSecurity#InfoSec#Samsung#LG